Nuclear Fusion – the reaction that powers the sun and stars has been an elusive dream of scientific community for decades. A fusion power plant fueled by burning plasmas, having temperatures of about 100 million K, could provide limitless amounts of clean and safe energy for humankind. All this by using just a small amount of electricity and a hand full of hydrogen isotopes. Isn’t it amazing?

Nuclear Fusion
Figure showing nuclear fusion of Deuterium and Tritium isotopes of Hydrogen

But the laboratory conditions cannot recreate the gravitational force that confines such highly energetic or in other words, high temperature charged particles. In fact, even the wall of the chamber in which fusion reaction is prospected to be carried out shall not be able to bear such highly energetic particle flux on its wall. We can understand this fact by considering that Tungsten is the metal having highest melting point of 3700 K. Can a crucible made of Tungsten contain a plasma having temperature an order of magnitude greater than that of Sun? No, certainly not!

To solve this problem, Fusion researchers came up with a couple of solutions:

Inertial Confinement

A way to confine high temperature plasmas in a fusion device is by using the technique of Inertial confinement (ICF). The plan is to initiate nuclear fusion reactions by heating and compressing a fuel target using high-energy laser beams. But still Inertial Confinement fusion experiments have failed to reach ignition. So we shall talk more about the challenges associated with another confinement technique called magnetically confined fusion in this article.

Related: Meet ITER – The Future of Energy Production
Video: How will the Sun die?

Magnetic Confinement

As we know that an applied magnetic field can deflect a particle’s trajectory and a charged particle moving with a velocity ‘v’ would generally follow a helical path around a magnetic field line ( See figure 1 ) . One way to confine a plasma in a nuclear fusion device with toroidal geometry is to use a cage of magnetic field lines that would confine the particles in such a way as to prevent their leaking to the walls of the fusion chamber. Such a device is called a tokamak.

Helical path of a charged particle in magnetic field lines
Figure1: Helical path ( in blue) of a charged particle due to applied magnetic field (field lines in red).
Magnetically confined plasma
Magnetically confined plasma

Now, we have some efficient confinement techniques, so what is stopping us from attaining fusion at a scale where we can have limitless amounts of electricity from it?

Another challenge is to heat the fusion plasmas to such high temperatures. The technique of Neutral Beam Injection (NBI) comes to the rescue.

Neutral Beam Injection

Neutral beam injection

Neutral Beam Injection is the technique in which high-energy neutral particles are injected in a magnetically confined fusion device. These neutral particles then undergo collisions with the thermal plasma ions and get ionized. So now that we have high-energy charged particles rather than neutral particles, they will further transfer their energy to the thermal ions by collisions and heat up the plasma. Also, once the nuclear reactions begin, they will generate their own energetic alpha particles as a by-product of fusion reactions. These energetic particles will help in keeping the plasmas hot and the nuclear reactions self-sustaining.

NBI working

But is it that simple? The answer is no.

Due to the complex geometry of magnetic field lines, there may arise some disturbances or perturbations as we say. These disturbances may give rise to certain waves such as Alfven waves in the fusion plasma. Now, the energetic particle may undergo resonant interactions with these waves, exchange energy with them and may drive them unstable.

Also read: Why Elon Musk wants to nuke Mars and how will it change the things forever?

Instabilities and Disruptions In a Nuclear Fusion Device

Imagine that you pluck a string of a guitar and it started vibrating with a particular amplitude and you hear the sound. Now what if you keep plucking the string again and again at that point with a higher force and the amplitude of vibration keeps on increasing. After some time, the string will break.

Similar things happen when you drive an old car and it starts vibrating at a particular speed. When you increase or decrease the speed slightly, the car stops vibrating. This is because at that speed, the different components of the car started vibrating with the same frequency and the frequency matching created resonance. Hence, the amplitude of vibration adds up to vibrate the car enough so that you can feel it.

The unstable modes of oscillations may then resonate with the energetic charged particles in a fusion plasma and the charged particles might deliver some of their energy to those oscillatory modes. So the amplitude of oscillations go on increasing that causes variation in charged particle trajectory and result in high-energy fluxes of energetic ions on the fusion chamber wall. Rapid growth in these instabilities may also cause disruptions in a plasma and hence poor plasma heating efficiency.

It is very important to understand the physical phenomena underlying the wave-particle interactions in a fusion plasma. Plasma physicists are using various simulation codes and comparing them with experiments to analyze the regime of operation of the neutral beam as well as alpha particles. We already have fusion devices that contain plasmas surpassing solar temperatures. But we still need to develop the technology and scientific understanding to sustain burning plasmas for hours or steady state.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Magnus Åkerfelt
Magnus Åkerfelt

When it says energetic neutral particles, what are those? Neutrons ? How are the neutral particles energized ? I take it the article isn’t referring to the neutrons freed in the fusion event since it says they are injected into the magnetic field.

Y N Andley
Y N Andley

B11 missing.
Q: How will high temperature create electricity?

alex cokonis
alex cokonis

When they achieve controlled sustained fusion it will become the greatest event in human history. But then again when you use solar energy you are using the biggest hydrogen fusion engine.


[…] Also Read: The challenges of building a Nuclear Fusion Power Plant […]

Shubh shankar jauhari
Shubh shankar jauhari

What happened if we build a magnetic wall like earth did to protect us we did for chamber

Yashika Ghai
Yashika Ghai

That’s exactly what is meant by the magnetic confinement. But instead of making it like magnetic field of Earth, we may try to imitate the magnetic field of the Sun as the plasma we are dealing with in Nuclwar fusion reactor has properties closer to that of Sun’s plasma. But the problem is that even the magnetic confinement in sun is not perfect! Time and again, certain charged particles from Sun leak out and propagate as solar wind towards Earth and other planets. So the challenge is to perfect this magnetic confinement scheme in a reactor while prevent the catastrophic events such as disruptions and instabilities from happening.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
Scroll to Top